Thomas Markle Sr. has been found competent to stand trial after a court-appointed forensic psychiatrist concluded that he was exaggerating his inability to remember or understand the criminal allegations against him to avoid prosecution.
US Magistrate Judge Lindsay Griffin accepted the findings during a November 19 hearing in Florida. Thomas Markle’s defence attorney, Mary Claire Wolf, did not contest the psychiatric evaluation, although the defence may revisit the issue once proceedings move to California.
The 82-year-old faces a federal charge of possessing child sexual abuse material (CSAM). Authorities arrested him on November 6 after FBI agents recovered approximately 78 items from two Los Angeles-area storage units he had rented since 2008.
The latest development follows previous reporting on Thomas Markle’s return to custody after an ankle monitor violation and the separate criminal investigation in the Philippines. Thomas Markle denies the allegations against him.
Psychiatrist Says Thomas Markle Exaggerated Symptoms to Avoid Prosecution
In a 16-page court filing dated November 16, Dr Amie Gerodimos, an assistant professor of psychiatry at the University of South Florida, concluded that Thomas Markle suffers from a genuine neurocognitive disorder of mild severity, possibly caused by vascular disease.
However, following a 90-minute evaluation at Pinellas County Jail on November 12, Gerodimos also identified malingering, the deliberate exaggeration or fabrication of symptoms for an external benefit.
She wrote:
It is my clinical opinion, with reasonable medical certainty, that Mr. Markle is malingering because he is exaggerating a lack of recall or understanding of the charges in order to avoid criminal prosecution.
Despite Thomas Markle repeatedly claiming that his memory was gone, Gerodimos observed good short-term memory, logical thinking and an understanding of criminal proceedings.
He could assess hypothetical plea agreements, identify the roles of courtroom participants and make decisions that took his age and health into account.
When presented with a hypothetical five-year prison sentence, Thomas Markle described it as effectively a death sentence because he believed he would not live that long. Gerodimos concluded that Thomas Markle understood the seriousness of the allegation and could properly assist his defence.
Samantha Markle Insisted Her Father Was Too Impaired to Proceed
The report also reveals details of Samantha Markle’s involvement in her father’s care following his initial release. Gerodimos had arranged to evaluate Thomas Markle at Samantha’s home on November 10, but Samantha informed her that her father was returning to court after removing his ankle monitor.
According to the psychiatrist, Samantha said her father had used a small knife to remove the device and had been acting angrily towards her.
Gerodimos described their telephone conversation:
She was adamant that he had dementia and that he was too dysregulated to proceed.
The psychiatrist repeatedly redirected the conversation to establish where she could conduct the evaluation, while Samantha continued expressing concerns about her father’s competency.
During the evaluation, Thomas Markle initially identified Thomas Jr. and Meghan as his only children. When Gerodimos asked about Samantha, he responded:
I don’t think so. I have two kids. I think Meghan is Samantha, I only have one daughter and one son.
Despite Samantha’s concerns, Thomas Markle’s defence team did not contest the psychiatrist’s competency findings at the November 19 hearing.
Samantha also supplied documents identifying her as her father’s healthcare proxy from August 8, 2026, alongside a handwritten note recording a purported transfer of power of attorney from Thomas Markle Jr. to her on September 9.
Gerodimos noted that the supplied screenshot of a physician’s assessment of Thomas Markle’s healthcare decision-making capacity lacked an attending physician’s signature. The report does not establish the legal validity of these documents.
Handwritten Notes Mention Caroline Grahm and Los Angeles Storage Lockers
One of the more striking revelations concerns handwritten notes Thomas Markle reportedly made when authorities approached him for arrest.
Kathy Yu supplied Gerodimos with a photograph of the notes, which contained the following phrases:
“Go to LA Secure Lockers,” “There is no porn in the lockers!!,” “Caroline Grahm,” “Go to L.A.,” and “LA-NOW.”
Gerodimos specifically noted that Yu said the criminal complaint was still sealed when Thomas Markle wrote them. The notes are particularly relevant given Thomas Markle’s subsequent claims that he could not remember or understand the allegations against him.
However, the report does not explain why Thomas Markle wrote Caroline Graham’s name, establish her identity or suggest that she participated in any wrongdoing.
Thomas Markle Accuses His Son and Denies Living in the Philippines
Throughout the evaluation, Thomas Markle repeatedly denied possessing child sexual abuse material and suggested that his son, Thomas Markle Jr., was responsible for his legal troubles.
“This sounds like my son is trying to set me up.”
Gerodimos interpreted Thomas Markle’s repeated references to his son, alongside his claims of memory loss, as evidence that he could formulate a potential defence strategy. The report provides no independent evidence supporting his accusations against Thomas Jr.
Thomas Markle also denied ever living in the Philippines, claiming he had visited the country approximately three times on holiday. He acknowledged having had a girlfriend there, insisting that she was above the age of consent. His account conflicts with ITV News reporting that he lived in Cebu until May 2026.
As we previously reported, Philippine police have submitted three alleged offences involving child sexual abuse and exploitation material to prosecutors in Cebu, who are evaluating the case. The Philippine investigation remains separate from the US federal proceedings.
Related Stories
What Happens Next?
Thomas Markle remains in custody, with a preliminary hearing reportedly scheduled for December 1 unless a grand jury indicts him beforehand.
Gerodimos acknowledged that Thomas Markle’s underlying health conditions place him at increased risk of further cognitive decline. She also explained that time constraints limited her evaluation and that she would consider additional medical records if they became available.
Nevertheless, her conclusion was clear: Thomas Markle currently possesses sufficient mental capacity to understand the criminal proceedings and assist in his defence.
The competency ruling allows the prosecution to proceed. It does not determine Thomas Markle’s guilt or innocence, and he remains presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Discover more from Feminegra
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

kikiki dude said about Scamatha, “Don’t know her, who is that”