Something very disturbing is happening, and we think it deserves attention. On 12 November, Celebitchy revealed that it had received repeated emails from someone allegedly “waging a campaign to convince media outlets to blame the Duchess of Sussex for her father’s depravity.”

According to Celebitchy, the correspondent sought to hold Meghan responsible for the Metropolitan Police’s handling of the allegations against Thomas Markle.

Well, that caught our attention because we have been receiving similar emails. Several of them, in fact. The messages repeat the same accusations: Meghan supposedly knew about the allegations for seven years, failed to protect children and has no business advocating for children’s safety.

The correspondence also invoked Florida’s child abuse reporting laws without providing evidence that those laws applied to Meghan’s circumstances, let alone that she had committed a criminal offence.

On 17 November, Complex covered Celebitchy’s account of the emails, noting that the existence of a wider, coordinated campaign had yet to be established.

What we can confirm, however, is that Celebitchy is not the only publication receiving correspondence promoting this narrative. Although we cannot establish whether the emails originated from the same individual, the similarities are striking. The fact that two independent publications have received messages encouraging them to blame Meghan for matters that fall within the remit of law enforcement deserves further scrutiny.

Similar Accusations Appear in The Telegraph

On November 13, Telegraph associate editor Camilla Tominey published a column questioning Meghan and Prince Harry’s response to the allegations against Thomas Markle.

In her article, Meghan has my sympathy, up to a point, Tominey revealed that someone identifying themselves as a survivor of child sexual abuse had contacted both her and royal editor Hannah Furness, questioning why the Sussexes had not done more to establish whether an investigation was taking place.

Although Tominey acknowledged that Meghan was not responsible for her father’s alleged crimes, she nevertheless questioned the couple’s decision not to discuss the allegations publicly, referencing their Oprah interview, Netflix documentary and Harry’s memoir.

Two days later, Tominey and Furness revisited the subject on their podcast in an episode entitled Why ‘haunted’ Meghan must speak out after Thomas Markle abuse claims.

We cannot establish any connection between The Telegraph’s correspondent and the individuals contacting Feminegra or Celebitchy. What we can identify, however, is a striking similarity in the arguments being promoted.

Why should Meghan be expected to publicly address allegations against her estranged father simply because she has previously spoken about her own experiences? His alleged conduct is not hers to explain, defend or answer for.

Collage showing Camilla Tominey’s December 2020 Telegraph article titled “Prince Andrew’s accuser was prostitute paid off by Jeffrey Epstein,” alongside her tweet promoting the story and a photo of her speaking with Prince Andrew. The article headline sparked backlash for its framing of Virginia Giuffre, who accused the Duke of York of sexual abuse when she was 17.

Tominey’s newfound emphasis on accountability is particularly interesting given her previous coverage of sexual abuse allegations involving the royal family.

In December 2020, she authored a Telegraph article that led with claims from court documents labelling Virginia Giuffre a prostitute, despite Giuffre’s allegations that Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell had sexually exploited and trafficked her as a teenager and that Prince Andrew had sexually abused her. The article’s framing attracted considerable criticism.

Six years later, Tominey is questioning Meghan over her estranged father’s alleged crimes. Why does the scrutiny in royal reporting so frequently fall on women rather than the men accused of abuse?

What Meghan Actually Said Versus the Narrative Being Pushed

And can we talk about the misinformation and deliberate narrative-setting? In her October statement, Meghan clearly said:

“That letter was subsequently shared with me.”

Meghan also stated that she received assurances that the allegations were being investigated. The Metropolitan Police confirmed receiving Roslyn Loveless’s letter in January 2019 and subsequently forwarding it to what officers described as the Sussexes’ office.

When the Met received the letter in January 2019, Harry and Meghan were still receiving household support from Kensington Palace. Buckingham Palace did not announce their separate royal household until March 2019, although Harry already had a private office. The Met has not publicly identified which royal officials, if any, handled the correspondence.

More concerningly, on 6 November, The Telegraph reported that the Met was still trying to identify and locate the royal protection officer who handed Meghan the letter. The original correspondence was reportedly missing, and Meghan had supplied police with her retained copy. Despite this, a source close to Meghan said the Met had not contacted her again to help identify the officer.

The police’s handling of the letter is now subject to two investigations. The Independent Office for Police Conduct is investigating the failure to notify other law enforcement agencies, while the Met’s Directorate of Professional Standards is examining the decision to forward the letter to the Sussexes’ office.

The Met explicitly stated that it forwarded the letter for the Sussexes’ awareness. That did not make Meghan responsible for investigating the allegations. Yet these correspondents expect her to answer for Scotland Yard’s decisions while questions about the royal household’s handling of the correspondence remain unresolved.

And where is the evidence that Meghan never followed up? The absence of publicly available information about private communications is not proof that those conversations never happened.

The British Press Should Answer the Same Questions It Asks Meghan

As we previously reported, The Sun acknowledged that Roslyn Loveless raised her concerns with the newspaper in 2018, before the Met’s recorded receipt of her letter.

The newspaper says it lacked sufficient evidence to publish or investigate further and that an alleged victim it approached denied the allegation.

But if royal commentators consider it reasonable to question Meghan’s actions after learning of the allegations, surely it is equally reasonable to ask what steps media organisations took after receiving similar warnings. Why should the standard of accountability be different?

The Vilification of Meghan Sussex Has Gone Too Far

The vilification of Meghan needs to stop. Repeatedly contacting independent publications to push unsupported accusations against her looks less like an attempt to manufacture negative headlines.

Children who have suffered abuse deserve justice, protection and accountability. Defending Meghan against unsupported accusations does not diminish their suffering. Exploiting these serious allegations to vilify a Black woman who faces no criminal accusations in connection with this case is disgusting.

For years, royal commentators criticised Meghan for distancing herself from Thomas Markle. Now, some are blaming her for supposedly not doing enough.

Which is it? Should Meghan have maintained contact with her father or kept her distance? Why should she have assumed responsibility for investigating his alleged conduct when, according to her, the police had already assured her that they were investigating?

The Metropolitan Police received serious allegations but failed to notify other law enforcement agencies. That failure is now under independent investigation. Meanwhile, Thomas Markle faces a federal criminal charge in the United States and three separate charges filed by Philippine police. He denies the allegations.

If these correspondents genuinely want accountability, they should focus on the people and institutions that investigators are scrutinising rather than trying to assign blame without evidence.