A federal judge has dismissed Justin Baldoni’s $400 million countersuit against Blake Lively, Ryan Reynolds, and several others, marking a decisive blow in the escalating legal battle tied to the production of the 2024 film It Ends With Us. The decision, handed down on June 9, 2025, by Judge Lewis J. Liman, concluded that Baldoni’s defamation and extortion allegations failed to meet the legal threshold required to proceed.

The lawsuit stemmed from public accusations made by Lively, who alleged Baldoni engaged in sexual harassment during the film’s production. Baldoni responded with a sweeping countersuit, claiming he was the target of a coordinated smear campaign — a charge that gained attention but ultimately lacked the legal heft to survive.

The Court Cites First Amendment Protections

In his ruling, Judge Liman invoked the landmark 1964 Supreme Court case New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, emphasizing that defamation claims brought by public figures must demonstrate actual malice or a reckless disregard for the truth. Baldoni’s filing, according to the court, did not present credible evidence of either.

This ruling follows the publication of text messages obtained by The New York Times, which appeared to show Baldoni’s team orchestrating a media strategy to counteract Lively’s allegations — a revelation that may have further undermined his legal standing.

Related | Blake Lively Files Lawsuit Against Justin Baldoni Over Sexual Harassment and Smear Campaign

The dismissal is notable in an era where defamation countersuits are increasingly used as a defensive strategy in celebrity scandals. Legal experts widely acknowledge how difficult it is to prove defamation against public figures, especially when First Amendment protections for speech and press are involved. Judge Liman’s ruling illustrates those challenges, emphasizing the high legal threshold for claims involving alleged harm to reputation.

Baldoni’s legal team has until June 23 to amend the lawsuit, but legal analysts say the bar remains high. For now, the spotlight returns to It Ends With Us and the wider conversation about accountability, narrative control, and the limits of celebrity influence in the courtroom.

Related | Judge Says Blake Lively Must Hand Over Taylor Swift Private Texts in Justin Baldoni Lawsuit

Key Sources For Justin Baldoni Dismissed Case

  • TMZ – Reported Lively filed to dismiss early, citing protections for harassment claims and privacy concerns over medical records.
  • CNN – Covered the June 9 dismissal, explaining the judge ruled Baldoni failed to prove “actual malice” under defamation law.
  • Variety – Confirmed all claims were dismissed, with a chance to amend contract interference allegations by June 23.

Discover more from Feminegra

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.