With Sadie Sink confirmed as Jean Grey, Kit Connor as Cyclops and Samara Weaving as Emma Frost, the buzz over who will play Ororo Munroe, a.k.a. Storm, is reaching a fever pitch. There is also online speculation that Ryan Coogler could have input into Storm’s casting, particularly with Black Panther 3, but Marvel has not confirmed his involvement in casting the character. But within the Black community, this casting has the potential to be explosive in a good or bad way.

Halle Berry and Alexandra Shipp, both biracial actresses, have portrayed Storm in live-action adaptations. Their castings reflect a longstanding Hollywood pattern: lighter-skinned and mixed-race Black actresses have often received greater visibility than dark-skinned actresses.

In Marvel comics, Storm traditionally appears as a dark-skinned Black woman of African heritage, worshipped as a goddess before she joined the X-Men. And fans have long wanted to see her portrayed accurately this time around. But this has already caused problems.

Chlöe Bailey’s Post Ignites the Debate

Chlöe Bailey posted that she is “a black girl who makes beats, builds legos, & reads comics,” accompanied by photos of comic books including Marvel’s Storm, a signed Catwoman issue, Thor, and a Medusa page. The post follows her direct responses to critics, where she noted her long-standing interest in comics and superheroes, including dressing as Storm for Halloween, and told detractors to get off her page. Chlöe has previously expressed interest in playing Storm. In 2022, after dressing as the character for Halloween, she told Variety she would love to take on the role. Chlöe reiterated in 2023 that she wanted the Marvel role, as she said: “I want to be Storm in Marvel“.

Given her previous comments, the posts were quickly interpreted as another expression of interest in the role.

However, the replies we reviewed were largely negative, with critics focusing on colourism and demanding that a dark-skinned Black woman play Storm.

Many commenters argue that Chlöe Bailey, while fully Black, is too light-skinned for Storm. They accused her of campaigning for the role and ignoring the character’s importance as a visibly dark-skinned Black woman. Some accuse her of entitlement or of perpetuating a pattern in which lighter-skinned actresses receive opportunities that should go to darker-skinned women.

Others take a more flexible view, noting that Storm has appeared in a range of skin tones and arguing that Chlöe is dark enough for the role. A smaller group argues that people are being overly sensitive and that she should ignore the backlash and pursue the role if she wants it.

Several replies insulted Chlöe directly, with some even saying they hope she does not get cast. Others framed their frustration around the broader lack of dark-skinned Black women in major Hollywood roles. The strongest sentiment did not question whether Chlöe is “Black enough.” Instead, fans argued that Storm carries cultural significance precisely because of her dark skin, and they do not want to see that representation diluted.

Chlöe Is Not the First Name in the Mix

None of this justifies attacking Chlöe Bailey because of her skin tone. Criticism of colourism and casting can be valid without turning into personal insults, bullying or questioning someone’s Blackness. Bailey’s original post was light-hearted, yet it quickly attracted hostility, so her frustration is understandable. The debate should stay focused on representation and why many fans want Storm portrayed by a dark-skinned Black woman, not on tearing down another Black woman.

Cynthia Erivo and SZA have both publicly said they would like to play Storm, while Ayo Edebiri has been linked to the role through casting rumours. Even Alexandra Shipp, who previously played Storm, has since said she would like to see a darker-complexioned woman take on the character, calling that representation something “the little girl in me” would like to see.

Final Thoughts

Black women, regardless of skin tone, have the right to see themselves in any iconic figure. Yet Hollywood has repeatedly given lighter-skinned and mixed-race actresses opportunities that dark-skinned Black actresses struggle to receive. I still find it shameful that the industry could not find a dark-skinned Black woman to play Nina Simone and instead relied on Zoe Saldaña using prosthetics.

Although I enjoy colour-blind casting and Storm is a fictional character, the pattern is hard to ignore. Hollywood has cast biracial women in every live-action adaptation of Storm, yet in comics and animation, she appears as an unambiguously dark-skinned Black woman. Why does animation and art freely embrace unambiguous Blackness while live-action adaptations consistently repress and lighten it?

And now there is another concern: age. With Sadie Sink confirmed as Jean Grey and Kit Connor as Cyclops, the X-Men cast is clearly skewing young. Whoever plays Storm needs to present as a peer, not as an older mentor figure. I am more worried that Marvel may cast her as an “auntie” or “mother” type, positioning her as support rather than a protagonist. I do not want to see her sidelined while we get yet another Phoenix storyline with Jean Grey taking top billing. Storm deserves to be a central figure in the new X-Men films, not reduced to a supporting role.

So while I will never begrudge any working actress getting the bag, I do understand why dark-skinned Black women feel the need to speak out regarding Storm. This could be Marvel’s best opportunity to have Storm portrayed accurately, unapologetically Black, and as a young leading figure, not a side character.

Discover more from Feminegra

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.