A cookbook created to support women affected by Grenfell somehow became a terrorism story, and the death of a 99-year-old prince became another opportunity to drag Meghan Sussex into the conversation. Media outlets have dissected her marriage, questioned her motives, and repeatedly dragged her name into stories that have little or nothing to do with her.

At some point, we have to stop asking why Meghan attracts so much negative coverage and start asking who is creating it, and how.

Complex reported on November 18 that we were the second publication to receive repeated emails urging journalists to blame Meghan for the allegations involving her estranged father, Thomas Markle. Thomas Markle denies wrongdoing. He faces a federal charge in the United States, while Philippine police have filed separate criminal complaints with prosecutors.

Celebitchy had already disclosed similar correspondence. The messages argued that Meghan knew about allegations involving her estranged father years ago and failed to act, even though she says police told her they were investigating the matter.

We cannot establish that the emails sent to Feminegra and Celebitchy came from the same person or that an organisation commissioned them. But people have publicly described being approached to create negative material about Meghan before.

Simon Rex Says Tabloids Offered Him $70,000 to Lie

Rex appeared with Meghan in a 2005 episode of Cuts. In a 2022 interview with The Guardian, he said several UK tabloids offered him $70,000 to claim that he had slept with her. Rex said they never slept together and that their off-screen contact went no further than one platonic lunch.

“I was broke as fuck,” he told the paper. He still refused.

Meghan later sent him a thank-you letter, which Rex said he framed. When the story resurfaced on social media, Rex publicly confirmed it again: “This is true.”

Rex was not being offered money for a genuine exclusive; he says the tabloids wanted him to sell them a story that was not true. At least one actor, then, says outlets actively tried to buy a lie about Meghan.

Media Outlets Went Looking for the Meghan Story They Wanted

Royal author Sarah Gristwood said in October 2019 that, after speaking with ‘a few tv/radio types,’ she realised some were ‘specifically looking for someone who’ll speak against Meghan.’ Gristwood refused.”

Anne Sebba, biographer of Wallis Simpson, described an even clearer example during a 2019 Rancho Mirage Writers Festival panel. Sebba said The Sun asked her to write an article comparing Meghan to Wallis, suggesting she could “destroy the royal family” and focusing on supposed tensions with Kate.

Sebba said she repeatedly explained that she could not make claims she could not verify them. The commissioning editor nevertheless spent around half an hour “twisting my arm,” suggesting things she “could say,” including allegations about Meghan firing staff. Sebba refused and later described the royal-media ecosystem as a “palace industry” that was “fanning” the flames.

The timing looks even more damning given what we have already reported about The Sun, Roslyn Loveless’s 2018 approach concerning Thomas Markle and Dan Wootton, who was an executive editor at the paper and part of its editing rota.

That raises an obvious question: who was the commissioning editor who spent half an hour trying to persuade Sebba to write those claims about Meghan? We have no evidence that it was Wootton, and he has since said he knew nothing about the allegations concerning Thomas Markle while working as executive editor of The Sun. But that has not stopped him from helping lead the charge against Meghan over what she supposedly knew. Methinks he doth protest too much.

Forensic psychologist Kerry Daynes later said “various media” approached her for negative commentary about Meghan. She refused. Psychologist Dr Helen Rodwell said she had received similar requests and turned them down too.

The Headlines Were Already Extreme

On November 23, 2018, The Telegraph published a Camilla Tominey story reporting claims from the Henry Jackson Society about people who had previously attended or been associated with Al-Manaar mosque, including Mohammed Emwazi, known as “Jihadi John.” The Hubb Community Kitchen operated from the mosque’s community space, but there was no allegation that the women running the kitchen, Meghan or the cookbook project had any involvement in extremism.

Those women had come together after the Grenfell Tower fire to cook for their families and neighbours in need. Meghan helped turn their work into a cookbook that raised money for the community. The then-Prince Charles had opened Al-Manaar in 2001, and the same mosque had also hosted Prince William and Prince Harry. Yet it was Meghan’s charitable project that ended up packaged alongside references to terrorism.

The reaction showed how that framing landed. Northern Irish right-wing commentator David Vance publicly thanked Tominey for putting what he called his “Meghan Markle ISIS Mosque cookbook story” on The Telegraph’s front page.

Three days later, Tominey published the story claiming Kate Middleton had been left in tears after a bridesmaid-dress fitting. Then, just days later, The Telegraph gave Carole Middleton her first major newspaper interview, a warm, flattering profile that stood in stark contrast to the coverage Meghan had just received.

We have examined that extraordinary November 2018 sequence in detail in the video above because it shows how quickly the coverage changed: from Meghan’s successful Oceania tour to terrorism, palace conflict and “Meghan made Kate cry.”

Then came Prince Philip’s death in April 2021. He was 99 and had recently spent weeks in hospital, yet Fox News host Brian Kilmeade still brought Harry and Meghan’s Oprah interview into the discussion, saying it had “definitely added to his stress.”

Now We Are Receiving the Pitches Ourselves

Celebitchy received three messages, two on November 9 and another on November 11, urging the site to blame Meghan for not taking further action after learning about allegations involving her father.

We also received three unsolicited emails pushing a remarkably similar argument. Two carried the same subject line and substantially repeated the same message, while another responded directly to our article, Piers Morgan Platformed Thomas Markle. Now He Questions Why Meghan Stayed Silent.

We have chosen not to identify the sender because we have not independently verified their identity. We have also removed personal information and allegations that are not necessary to show what we were being asked to do.

One message criticised our coverage before telling us:

“I do hope your future coverage will shine a light on who the true victims are – and they are not the Sussexes.”

Another went further:

“I respectfully urge you to report on what the vast majority of the public is concerned with.”

The same email concluded:

“The time has come for the media to acknowledge the hypocrisy of the Sussexes.”

These were not simply readers telling us they disagreed with something we had written. The messages explicitly urged us to change how we covered Meghan and Harry and to adopt a particular conclusion about them.

Celebitchy found that its emails were sent using eM Client 11.0.0.0, a commercially available email application. The similarities in the wording and arguments, not the choice of email software, give us reason to suspect the same person may have contacted both publications. However, the evidence does not yet allow us to confirm that or determine whether anyone else or an organisation was involved.

So Who Is Paying Whom?

After everything above, asking who benefits from this ecosystem is not unreasonable.

Simon Rex says British tabloids offered him $70,000 to invent a sexual relationship with Meghan. Anne Sebba says a Sun commissioning editor spent half an hour trying to persuade her to make claims about Meghan that she repeatedly said she could not verify. Sarah Gristwood and Kerry Daynes described media outlets actively searching for negative Meghan commentary. Now Feminegra and Celebitchy have received repeated messages urging us to adopt another blame-Meghan narrative.

We do not need to invent a vast conspiracy to recognise what those examples show. There is a documented appetite for negative Meghan material, and on several occasions people have described journalists or media organisations actively trying to produce it.

That does not mean every critic has been paid. It does mean we should stop pretending that every anti-Meghan narrative simply appears organically.

When Will Enough Be Enough?

The latest attempt to make Meghan responsible for her estranged father is particularly revealing.

The Metropolitan Police had the allegations. Police passed them to Harry and Meghan’s office and, according to the Met’s own records, failed to share them with other law-enforcement agencies. Yet once Thomas Markle faced serious allegations, parts of the commentary class turned their attention back to Meghan and demanded to know why she had not done more. That is backwards.

For years, sections of the press gave Thomas Markle a platform while portraying his estranged daughter as cruel for cutting him off. They pursued Meghan’s family disputes, amplified attacks against her, and repeatedly treated reconciliation with her father as something she owed him. Now some of the same media ecosystem wants to turn his alleged conduct into another indictment of her.

Meghan did not create these allegations, nor did she control how the Met handled them. Police had the letter, informed Harry and Meghan through Kensington Palace, and chose not to pass the allegations to other law-enforcement agencies.

And this article shows something else: when people refused to supply sufficiently negative Meghan commentary, some outlets kept looking. When one actor would not lie about sleeping with her for money, he says the offer was still made. When Sebba said she could not verify allegations, she says an editor continued pushing.

So no, the question is no longer simply why Meghan attracts so much hostile coverage. It is why, after all these years, so many people still seem determined to manufacture another reason to blame her.

When will enough be enough?


Discover more from Feminegra

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.