An AI-generated image of Donald Trump dressed as the pope has ignited fierce backlash from Catholic leaders and political observers. The post, originally shared by Trump on Truth Social and later amplified by the official White House X account, shows the former president seated in papal robes and a gilded mitre. The timing of the image—just days after the funeral of Pope Francis—struck many as disrespectful and calculated.
There is nothing clever or funny about this image, Mr. President. We just buried our beloved Pope Francis and the cardinals are about to enter a solemn conclave to elect a new successor of St. Peter. Do not mock us. https://t.co/ortxbkDlT5
— NYS Catholic Conference (@NYSCatholicConf) May 3, 2025
Among the first to condemn it was the New York Catholic Conference of Bishops. “Do not mock us,” their statement read, calling out Trump for making light of a sacred moment. The group, led by Trump’s longtime ally Cardinal Timothy Dolan, made clear their grief and displeasure. The Church is now preparing for a May 7 conclave to choose a new pontiff, while public outrage continues to build online.
Catholic Leaders And Conservative Defenders Clash
Despite the backlash, Trump has not apologized. Instead, he added fuel to the fire earlier this week by joking that he should be the next pope. When pressed, he floated Dolan as an alternative. Dolan, notably, has remained silent, despite years of public praise for Trump. He once prayed at both of Trump’s inaugurations and has referred to him as a sincere man of faith.
The silence from Dolan contrasts sharply with the reaction of his colleagues. Many see the image not just as a joke, but as a direct insult to Pope Francis, who died at 88 after suffering a stroke on Easter Monday. Francis had often criticized Trump’s politics, especially on immigration. Still, Trump and Melania sat in the front row at his funeral, drawing attention from the Catholic world.
Vice President JD Vance, a Catholic convert who visited the Vatican shortly before Francis died, came to Trump’s defense. Asked on social media if he supported the image, Vance deflected by criticizing U.S. foreign policy. Others, like MSNBC’s Michael Steele and director Morgan J. Freeman, called the post shameful and childish. Critics pointed to the sacred nature of the papacy and said mocking it, especially while the Church mourns, crossed a line.
Related | Pope Leo XIV Makes History as First American Pontiff Amid Hopes and Uncertainty
The Obama Comparison Fuels Debate Over Hypocrisy
As the controversy spread, many began drawing comparisons to how conservatives reacted during Barack Obama’s presidency. When Obama wore a tan suit in 2014, right-wing media exploded with outrage, calling it disrespectful and unpresidential. Trump’s image, however, showed him in a full papal ensemble—including a tan mitre—days after the pope’s death. Yet many MAGA supporters celebrated the post or dismissed concerns altogether.
Social media users quickly noticed the contradiction. “Imagine if this had been Obama, Biden, or Kamala,” one post read. Others joked that if an AI image of Pope Obama had gone viral, conservative pundits would have declared a moral crisis. Instead, Trump’s supporters praised the image or waved it off as harmless satire.
The incident also raised broader concerns about political manipulation through AI. Though the image may appear humorous to some, its release by the White House blurred the line between propaganda and parody. Catholic institutions expressed frustration that their faith was being treated as a meme, especially during a time of mourning and transition.
Related | White South African Refugees Receive VIP Treatment
Why Donald Trump Can’t Be The Pope
While Trump may enjoy the imagery, Church law makes his fantasy impossible. Only a baptized Catholic can become pope, and Trump does not meet that basic requirement. Even if he did, Canon Law adds another barrier, requiring candidates to be “of sound mind.” The National Catholic Register cheekily pointed this out, as Senator Lindsey Graham urged Americans to “keep an open mind,” seemingly playing along with the absurdity.
What began as a provocative image has now become a flashpoint in America’s ongoing culture war. As the Vatican prepares to choose the next leader of the Catholic Church, the rest of the world watches Donald Trump once again make himself the center of attention—this time in holy robes.
Discover more from Feminegra
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.