Media Erasure or Racism? Cynthia Erivo’s ‘Wicked’ Treatment Sparks Outrage

The film adaptation of Wicked has generated significant excitement, particularly with Cynthia Erivo stepping into the iconic role of Elphaba. As the first Black actress to portray Elphaba on film, Erivo’s casting marks a historic moment in the reimagining of a beloved musical that has long captivated audiences. Despite her prominence as the lead, British media coverage has overwhelmingly focused on her co-star, Ariana Grande, who plays Glinda.

Related | Media Dehumanization of Black Victims and the Tragic Case of Daniel Anjorin

Media Coverage Disparity with Cynthia Erivo vs. Ariana Grande

The media coverage surrounding Cynthia Erivo and her Wicked co-star Ariana Grande illustrates a clear difference in attention given to the two actors. While both play leading roles, Erivo as Elphaba and Grande as Glinda, British media has largely focused on Grande. Major publications and media outlets have highlighted Grande more prominently, often sidelining Erivo despite her central role in the film.

Promotional features and press coverage have frequently overlooked Erivo, despite her role as the lead character. Interviews and articles tend to emphasize Grande’s status as a pop star and her role in the movie, with Erivo’s portrayal receiving less attention. This pattern reflects a recurring issue within the media’s treatment of Black talent, particularly Black British actors. Even in joint interviews, interviewers often direct questions at Grande, making Erivo’s contributions less visible.

This coverage disparity highlights a broader problem of unequal recognition. While Grande’s celebrity status may draw media interest, it should not come at the expense of recognizing Erivo’s work and her key role in the film. The lack of equal coverage illustrates ongoing challenges faced by Black British actors in gaining recognition and visibility in their own country, leading many to seek opportunities abroad.

The Fan-Made Poster Controversy and Its Significance

A fan-made edit of the Wicked movie poster circulated online and sparked significant controversy. The edit featured Cynthia Erivo’s Elphaba with her eyes obscured by her hat, mimicking the original Broadway design. Erivo publicly criticized the edit, expressing that it was offensive and made her feel erased. Her reaction shed light on deeper concerns about representation, particularly for Black actors in high-profile roles.

Cynthia Erivo reacts to viral fan edit of the ‘WICKED’ poster via Instagram:

“This is the wildest, most offensive thing I have seen, equal to that awful Ai of us fighting, equal to people posing the question "is your ***** green" (…) It degrades me It degrades us The original… pic.twitter.com/aeBf8me4Ko

— Pop Base (@PopBase) October 16, 2024

Erivo’s criticism demonstrated the sensitivity around how mainstream media depicts and recognizes Black talent. While some fans argued that the edit was an homage to the original musical’s imagery, others supported Erivo, acknowledging her frustration with a design choice that diminished her visibility.

The controversy around the poster is more than a singular incident; it reflects the challenges faced by Black actors in maintaining control over their image and representation. Erivo called for recognition and respect for the work and prominence she brings to her role. The discussion also touched on the tension between fan interpretations and the lived experiences of artists, demonstrating how even well-meaning tributes can unintentionally perpetuate harmful patterns of erasure. This incident became a focal point for broader conversations about representation, visibility, and respect within the entertainment industry.

Historical and Systemic Issues in British Media

The treatment of Cynthia Erivo in Wicked promotion sheds light on long-standing issues within British media regarding the erasure and marginalization of Black talent. This problem is not new; historically, Black British actors and artists have struggled to receive the same recognition and visibility as their white counterparts. The media’s consistent focus on Ariana Grande, despite Erivo also being the main character, highlights a pattern where Black actors are often overshadowed or sidelined.

Many Black British artists have voiced similar experiences, noting the systemic nature of underrepresentation and bias in British media coverage. This lack of acknowledgment has driven numerous Black creatives to seek success abroad, often in the United States, where they find more opportunities and appreciation. While some British outlets attempt to promote diversity, the underlying structures often maintain a preference for white talent, reinforcing inequality.

The erasure experienced by Erivo resonates with broader societal issues in the UK, where racism in media practices mirrors other forms of institutional bias. The British media’s treatment of Meghan Markle illustrates how narratives are manipulated to marginalize and undermine individuals of color, regardless of their contributions or status. Erivo’s experience reflects the persistent challenges of gaining recognition and respect in an environment that still grapples with systemic discrimination.

The Irony of Erasure in the Context of Wicked

Wicked tells the story of Elphaba, a character who is ostracized and misunderstood due to her differences. Cynthia Erivo’s portrayal of Elphaba in the film adaptation embodies this narrative, yet the media’s treatment of Erivo ironically mirrors the same themes of exclusion and erasure present in the story. While Wicked explores prejudice and the struggles of being marginalized, Erivo’s experience highlights how real-life systemic issues persist, even as she plays a character who symbolizes resilience against bias.

Embed from Getty Images

The media’s focus on her co-star, Ariana Grande, while overlooking Erivo’s central role is ironic. Erivo, a Black British actress, should represent a moment of progress and inclusivity, especially in a story about breaking stereotypes and overcoming social exclusion. Instead, the lack of recognition for her work reveals the ongoing reluctance of institutions to fully embrace and celebrate Black talent.

By failing to give Erivo her due spotlight, British media reinforces the very dynamics Wicked seeks to challenge. The story’s themes resonate deeply with those who feel unseen and undervalued, yet Erivo’s own journey illustrates how far there is still to go in breaking these cycles of marginalization. This erasure becomes more glaring in a narrative that revolves around challenging prejudice, making it all the more essential to address and correct these disparities in real-life representation.