It’s Black History Month in the UK, and King Charles is preparing for a Caribbean tour that will take him to The Bahamas, Guyana and Antigua and Barbuda without offering a formal apology for Britain’s role in the transatlantic slave trade.

Buckingham Palace says Charles will acknowledge what he has previously called the “darkest days of our past.” But there will be no apology and no commitment to financial reparations. The UK government maintains that position, and the King acts on ministerial advice.  

So we are apparently getting sorrow without an apology and acknowledgement without restitution.

Charles has previously described slavery as an “atrocity” that “forever stains our history.” Buckingham Palace insists he will not “shy away” from the subject during the Caribbean tour. Yet refusing to apologise while repeatedly describing the horror of what happened looks increasingly difficult to square.

The Crown Was Not a Bystander

This is not simply a discussion about something Britain did hundreds of years ago while the monarchy watched from the sidelines.

The Crown had direct institutional links to the trade. Charles II granted a charter to the Royal African Company in 1672. His brother James, Duke of York, later King James II, served as its governor and invested in it. The company transported around 150,000 enslaved Africans across the Atlantic, more than any other single organisation involved in the transatlantic trade.

Many captives transported by the Royal African Company were branded “DY” for the Duke of York. Separate research into the South Sea Company has now found evidence that enslaved Africans were branded with an identifying mark incorporating the British Crown itself. 

That history makes the Palace’s talk of merely “acknowledging the wrongs of the past” look like an attempt to confront slavery without accepting responsibility for it. The monarchy still derives its authority from lineage, inheritance and centuries of institutional continuity. It celebrates that continuity through crowns, palaces, ceremonies, collections and titles. It therefore cannot treat the darker parts of that same institutional history as though they belong to somebody else.

The monarchy’s involvement in slavery is documented. The Crown chartered slave-trading enterprises, while monarchs and other royals invested in them. The monarchy still claims legitimacy through hereditary continuity, preserving centuries-old titles, ceremonies, property and royal collections. Charles cannot celebrate that continuity when it confers status and privilege, then treat its darker history as belonging to somebody else.

Sorrow Still Is Not an Apology

The government argues that Britain has no legal obligation to pay reparations for acts that were not prohibited by international law at the time. Caribbean governments continue to challenge that position and have pushed for formal apologies and reparatory justice. Jamaica recently filed a petition asking the King to refer legal questions about slavery and reparations to the Privy Council.  

And this is why the distinction between sorrow and apology matters. Charles can say slavery was atrocious. He can say it stains British history. He can express personal sorrow every time the issue returns.

Other leaders have gone further. In 2023, King Willem-Alexander formally apologised for the Netherlands’ role in slavery and asked forgiveness for his dynasty’s failure to act. New research presented to him on 2 October 2026 went further, concluding that Dutch rulers actively supported colonialism and slavery. Willem-Alexander publicly acknowledged those findings. Pope Leo XIV has also formally asked forgiveness in the name of the Catholic Church for its historic complicity in slavery.

Going into this tour with a formal apology already off the table and the government continuing to rule out reparations does not look like confronting history. It looks like carefully managing how much responsibility the British state and monarchy are prepared to own.


Discover more from Feminegra

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.