When Kensington Palace announced that Kate Middleton had completed the National Three Peaks Challenge, the framing was carefully crafted. The media sold it as a solo mission to “explore life beyond diagnosis” and raise money for cancer care. Even though she had a camera crew on hand, the photographs released to the public showed her at the summit, alone, smiling bravely against the wind.

Then a fellow climber, Phillip Tebajjwa, posted a video that told a slightly different story. The footage showed Kate descending Snowdon Summit with her brother, James Middleton, walking beside her. James held her hand at one point. One of his dogs walked alongside them. It was a small detail, but it complicated the neat narrative of a lone hero battling the elements.

Philip later took down the video and apologised. He said he had handed the footage to Kensington Palace so they could “deal with the media interest.”

Advertisement

Here is what People reported:

A new video shared to a fellow hiker’s Instagram Stories on June 30 showed that Princess Kate descended Mount Snowdon in Wales hand‑in‑hand with her brother James, 39.

“There I was, congratulating fellow climbers as they made their way down from the windy summit… little did I know I was actually speaking to royalty,” entrepreneur Phillip Tebajjwa wrote in part over the video.

James also supported his sister by commenting on her Instagram post revealing her weekend adventure, writing, “So proud,” with a heart and mountain emoji.

A close look at the new video showed that Kate and James were joined by a special companion: one of James’ six dogs, who walked beside him.

Tebajjwa also shared a photo with Kate and wrote over it, “The Princess of Wales just stopped to congratulate me on completing the challenge… and then agreed to take a selfie. At that moment, I could only think one thing… Am I actually dreaming?”

The Palace Cannot Have It Both Ways

The issue is not that Kate had support. Most people completing a challenge like this would have support. The issue is that the public was repeatedly fed language that made the achievement sound solitary, only for organic footage from a public mountain to show her brother right there beside her.

Composite image showing People, Hello and The Guardian reporting that Kate Middleton completed the Three Peaks Challenge solo with Mountain Rescue support.

Again, James’ being present is not the problem. If anything, it makes the story warmer. A brother supporting his sister after her recovery is far more moving than another palace-produced solo heroine narrative. So why was the footage treated as if it needed to disappear?

That is the part that feels revealing. A member of the public posted a normal hiking clip after bumping into Kate on Snowdon. The clip showed something harmless: Kate, James, a dog, and other hikers in a public space. But once it complicated the polished media framing, the video came down, Philip issued an apology, and Kensington Palace reportedly ended up with the rights.

And Philip was not the only hiker whose footage showed James with Kate. Other organic footage shared on Instagram also appeared to place him alongside her during the challenge. Will they be contacted to remove it by the palace and be made to apologise as well?

That is not how authenticity works. Kensington Palace cannot invite the public to celebrate a personal, emotional, “private” challenge while also trying to control every stray piece of footage that makes the story less cinematic. Real moments are messy, and real family support is visible.

Kate’s Hiking Story Fits An Old Palace Pattern

This feels very reminiscent of the media narrative that Kate did her own makeup on her wedding day. For years, many outlets repeated that framing without any meaningful correction from the Palace. Years later, Bobbi Brown said what the Palace never did: Kate had help.

And honestly, she should have. She was getting married in front of the entire world. The idea that she would be sitting there doing her own full bridal makeup for a global royal wedding always felt absurd.

And who can forget the Paris Match photos from their ski trip to Courchevel? The same trip that showed Kate looking perfectly healthy on the slopes, just weeks after the Palace had been using her recovery as a shield for her low engagement count.

That same absurdity carries into this latest hiking story. Plenty of people do charity hikes with friends, family or support teams. So it already felt strange that Kate’s Three Peaks challenge was framed as though she completed it entirely alone. Never mind the obvious reality that she would require security, logistics, support, and staff. And if this was logged as a working engagement, then it was not just a private personal challenge either.

So why the need to keep presenting Kate as the woman who does everything by herself? That is the part that feels forced. The Palace keeps building these narratives around Kate as effortlessly perfect, endlessly humble and quietly self-sufficient. But the more they push that image, the less authentic it feels.

Final Thoughts

Now the story gets even stranger. These hikes, described in intensely personal terms, were also logged in the Court Circular as official royal engagements.

So which is it? Was this a private family challenge, supported by James Middleton and even one of his dogs? Or was it official royal work? If it was private, why is it being counted as duty? And if it was official duty, why did so much of the coverage lean into the image of Kate quietly doing it alone?

That is where Kensington Palace’s problem begins. They want the emotional power of a private family story and the institutional credit of an official engagement. They want Kate praised as brave, humble and low-key, while also banking the appearance as royal work.

But the Snowdon footage shows why over-managed royal storytelling can backfire. James being there would have made the story better. Instead, because the coverage leaned so heavily on “solo” language, his presence became a PR problem.

So are we meant to count this as family support, private healing, charity fundraising or official royal duty? Or does Kensington Palace simply pick whichever version works best in the moment?

Discover more from Feminegra

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.