Prince William and Kate Middleton arrived in Mumbai this week with a very polished version of environmental diplomacy. There was gully cricket with Sachin Tendulkar, cutting chai, a ride on the Mumbai Metro and the biggest Earthshot Prize ceremony yet, packed with Bollywood stars, musicians and 5,000 guests.

The official message was optimism: five environmental solutions each received £1 million, while Earthshot presented India as a centre of innovation and climate leadership.

But once the royal cameras moved on, some of the most interesting coverage started coming from India itself. And it was considerably less interested in designer clothes and royal diplomacy.

Times of India Asked Why India Is Still Swooning

In a November 18 Times of India video, Meghna Deka asked a much bigger question: why should India still roll out the royal treatment for representatives of a monarchy so closely tied to British imperial history?

The segment revisited economist Utsa Patnaik’s estimate that Britain drained roughly $45 trillion from India between 1765 and 1938. Patnaik arrived at that figure by calculating India’s export-surplus earnings and compounding them at a 5% interest rate. The exact scale of the colonial drain remains debated, but the underlying transfer of enormous resources from India to Britain is well established.

Deka also raised the 1943 Bengal famine, during which millions died. British parliamentary records confirm that India exported roughly 70,000 tonnes of rice during the first seven months of 1943 even as famine conditions developed. The programme also raised the Koh-i-Noor and Britain’s continuing reluctance to offer the kind of formal apology demanded in former colonies.

That is a very different backdrop from the one royal coverage usually gives us. The British press showed William and Kate riding the Mumbai Metro as environmental statespeople. Indian coverage was asking what exactly Britain expects former colonies to forget when a future king arrives asking everyone to focus on sustainability and shared progress.

You cannot talk endlessly about repairing the planet while treating history as something that conveniently began when Earthshot launched in 2020.

Mumbai Apparently Shines When Royalty Comes to Town

Then came the Bombay High Court. The court was hearing a case about Mumbai’s waste problems when judges pointed to how quickly authorities had transformed areas of the city for important visitors.

They did not name William and Kate, and there is no suggestion that the couple ordered the clean-up. But The Indian Express reported that the judges specifically referred to Ballard Estate, where William and Kate had played cricket days earlier, suddenly looking polished and clean. The court questioned why residents could not receive that standard permanently rather than authorities putting on what it called a temporary show for guests.

That criticism becomes especially awkward in the context of an environmental prize. The Times of India had already reported that ahead of the royal visit, roads around Ballard Estate were washed, tree beds tidied, rubbish removed and works accelerated in preparation for William and Kate’s appearance.

Meanwhile, the High Court was discussing heaps of plastic waste and pollution at the Kanjurmarg landfill and asking why Mumbai was not taking more aggressive action against plastic.

Nobody needs to pretend William secretly ordered municipal workers out with hoses and paintbrushes. The problem is the image it produced.

Royal audiences were shown a clean, orderly Mumbai as William promoted a prize dedicated to repairing the planet. Residents then watched judges ask why their own city receives that level of attention only when important guests arrive. That is exactly how environmental work becomes PR.

Embed from Getty Images

Earthshot’s Winners Should Have Been the Story

There is another problem, and people who attended Earthshot noticed it too. The ceremony featured Karan Johar, Alia Bhatt, Sonam Kapoor, Rami Malek, Sachin Tendulkar, Simone Ashley, Take That and a long list of entertainment names. Earthshot itself heavily promoted the celebrity line-up in advance.

Visibility matters. Celebrities can bring an audience to environmental work. But visibility is supposed to lead people towards the work, not become the work.

The five winners included Bhutan’s water-protection programme, France’s movement against PFAS chemicals, the Niue Ocean Wide Trust, Mahindra’s electric three-wheelers and Ørsted’s transition from coal towards offshore wind. Those stories deserved far more attention than another round of royal fashion coverage.

When people come away from an environmental awards ceremony knowing what Kate wore but struggling to name the people who actually won, something has gone wrong with the storytelling. Star power should shine the spotlight on innovators. It should not swallow them whole.

And These Questions About Earthshot Aren’t New

The criticism did not start in Mumbai. In 2024, Inside Philanthropy asked experienced environmental funders what they thought of Earthshot. Former Hewlett Foundation president Larry Kramer questioned why something he considered relatively small attracted so much attention. Walter Reid, who spent years leading the Packard Foundation’s environment programme, questioned whether Earthshot’s £1 million prizes matched its ambition to fund “moonshots” and raised concerns about its selection model.

Former Sustainable Agriculture and Food Systems Funders leader Virginia Clarke was even less impressed, arguing that Earthshot moved surprisingly little money considering the wealth of some of its backers. The same investigation noted Earthshot’s own 2024 impact report showed guest travel accounted for 47% of its organisational footprint.

To be clear, Earthshot can point to results. It says the 75 finalists from its first five cohorts collectively avoided or captured more than 18 million tonnes of CO₂, protected or restored 58 million hectares of land and 85 million hectares of ocean and coastline, and removed or avoided 465,000 tonnes of waste.

So the argument is not that every Earthshot project is worthless. It is whether the spectacle surrounding the prize has become disproportionately focused on William, celebrity guests and the annual travelling royal show rather than the people actually doing the environmental work. Mumbai has made that question harder to ignore.

The Palace Got Its Pictures. Mumbai Kept the Garbage.

The royal visit produced exactly the images Kensington Palace would have wanted: William and Kate on public transport, playing cricket with children and standing alongside people working on climate solutions.

But Indian journalists, commentators and now the Bombay High Court have supplied the missing background.

The freshly polished streets were temporary. The landfill was still there. The colonial history was still there. And the environmental innovators risked becoming supporting characters at their own awards ceremony.

That does not make William personally responsible for Mumbai’s municipal failures, nor does it erase the genuine work of Earthshot’s finalists.

But an environmental prize built around the future king cannot ask audiences to look only where the palace camera is pointing. If Earthshot wants to sell itself as a serious response to the climate crisis, then the real environmental conditions outside the green carpet matter too.

And perhaps the most revealing image from Earthshot Mumbai is not William and Kate riding through a spotless metro station. It is a court asking why ordinary Mumbaikars cannot expect the same care once the royal guests have gone home.


Discover more from Feminegra

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.