Aliyah Mastin is heading to Riverdale. The actress, who plays Presley Collins, the daughter of Sterling K. Brown’s character in Hulu’s Paradise, has landed the role of Veronica Lodge in Disney+’s upcoming horror series Afterlife With Archie.

Deadline exclusively reported on November 19 that Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa had found his new Archie, Betty, Veronica, Jughead and Sabrina for the live-action adaptation of the horror comic he created with artist Francesco Francavilla.

The series, which comes from Warner Bros. Television and Berlanti Productions, is targeting a Halloween 2027 premiere. We love this casting for Mastin. However, considering Aguirre-Sacasa’s television track record, we have some reservations about the writing.

Meet the New Afterlife With Archie Cast

The five actors taking on the iconic Archie Comics characters are: Vasco Faria will play Archie Andrews, with Aliyah Mastin as Veronica Lodge, Sarah Abbott as Betty Cooper, Angel Rivera as Jughead Jones and Chloe Avakian as Sabrina Spellman.

First published in 2013, Afterlife With Archie reimagines Riverdale as the setting of a zombie apocalypse. In the original comics, Sabrina attempts to resurrect Jughead’s beloved dog, but her spell goes horribly wrong. The undead soon overrun Riverdale, forcing Archie and his friends to fight for survival.

The source material offers plenty of opportunities to explore friendship, romance, betrayal and survival without sacrificing the personalities that made these characters so popular.

Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa’s Writing Is Our Biggest Concern

If there is one thing Aguirre-Sacasa knows how to do, it is create a visually appealing television series with an attractive and talented cast. His ability to maintain a compelling storyline, however, is another matter.

Both Riverdale and Chilling Adventures of Sabrina had promising premises, memorable casting choices and distinctive aesthetics. Yet their increasingly chaotic storylines often undermined what made those shows appealing in the first place.

There comes a point when the constant twists become so ridiculous that you stop caring about the characters and start wondering what bizarre storyline the writers will introduce next. Hopefully, having an established horror comic to work from will encourage Aguirre-Sacasa to exercise some restraint this time.

Aliyah Mastin Deserves Better Than Hollywood’s Predictable Casting Backlash

Our other concern is how audiences will treat Mastin if the series struggles creatively. We have repeatedly seen Black actresses cast in traditionally white fictional roles, only to find themselves blamed for problems that have absolutely nothing to do with their performances.

Poor dialogue, inconsistent character development and questionable creative decisions suddenly become debates about race and casting rather than the quality of the writing.

Aguirre-Sacasa’s storytelling choices attracted criticism long before Mastin joined this project. If those same problems emerge in Afterlife With Archie, they should not become an excuse to target its Black female lead.

Mastin has already demonstrated her talent in Paradise, and we are excited to see her interpretation of Veronica Lodge. Let her be glamorous, ambitious, complicated, occasionally selfish and every bit as entertaining as the character deserves to be.

Disney+ has assembled a promising cast. Now it needs to give them scripts worthy of their talent.


Discover more from Feminegra

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.