The Acolyte, the 2024 Star Wars series, outperformed Daredevil: Born Again in its debut week, despite being the show that Disney quietly cut loose. According to the studio’s official metrics, The Acolyte pulled in 11.1 million views in its first five days. In contrast, Daredevil: Born Again reached 7.5 million over the same timeframe.

The numbers are public. The fallout, less so.

A Strong Start for Star Wars

When The Acolyte launched on June 4, 2024, it drew 4.8 million views on its first day. That made it Disney+’s biggest series debut of the year at the time. The early response was swift and sizable, fueled by curiosity and the enduring pull of the Star Wars universe. By the end of 2024, the show amassed 2.67 billion minutes watched, according to Nielsen, making it the second-most-viewed Disney+ series of the year behind Percy Jackson and the Olympians.

Initial enthusiasm for The Acolyte was clear. According to Nielsen, the show’s two-episode premiere during the week of June 3 to June 9, 2024, pulled in 488 million minutes watched in the U.S., translating to around 6.26 million views based on runtime. But the momentum slowed. By the following week, viewership dropped to 370 million minutes, with three episodes available. As new episodes rolled out, the show consistently fell below Nielsen’s Top 10 threshold, which hovered between 298 and 341 million minutes. The only exception came in week seven, when the finale aired and viewership rose to 335 million minutes—just enough to re-enter the Top 10.

This pattern—strong debut, mid-season dip, finale bump—is common across streaming series. But in The Acolyte’s case, it marked a shift in how the show was framed publicly. Despite outperforming Daredevil: Born Again in early viewership, The Acolyte was quickly reframed as a costly misstep. Critics and culture war pundits now cite it as the “woke” scapegoat blamed for damaging Disney+ as a whole—shifting focus from metrics to messaging.

Marvel’s Slower Burn

Daredevil: Born Again premiered on March 4, 2025, with a global viewership of 7.5 million over five days. It became the most-watched Disney+ debut of 2025 so far, though its numbers trailed not only The Acolyte but also Marvel predecessors like Loki Season 2 and Agatha All Along. Still, Disney announced a second season. The message was clear: Marvel’s reputation buys more time.

Unlike The Acolyte, Daredevil lacked Nielsen data at the time of reporting, making it difficult to gauge long-term traction. What is clear is that the response leaned positive. Fans have praised its grounded tone and faithful handling of Matt Murdock’s legacy. Yet the show didn’t generate the same immediate cultural chatter.

High Budgets and Higher Expectations

According to The New York Times, The Acolyte had a production budget of around $180 million, confirmed by showrunner Leslye Headland. Later reports placed the budget closer to $230 million. Disney later cited that cost—alongside a drop in episode-to-episode retention—as its reason for cancelling a second season. But that explanation appears inconsistent when placed next to the data. The Acolyte opened with 11.1 million views in its first five days, outperforming Daredevil: Born Again, which drew 7.5 million in the same period.

Yet Daredevil was renewed with little hesitation, despite drawing fewer viewers. Disney has not disclosed its budget, but industry estimates place it near $200 million—making it one of Marvel’s most expensive shows. If cost-cutting was the main concern, the numbers suggest otherwise.

Adding to the contradiction is the company’s investment in Andor. According to Disney’s public filings, the Star Wars prequel series has reached a production cost of $645 million, including a record $290.9 million spent on its second season alone. That makes Andor the most expensive Star Wars project on record—surpassing even The Last Jedi and The Force Awakens.

These figures complicate the way Disney appears to define value. The Acolyte cost less than both Andor and Daredevil, launched with stronger numbers than the latter, yet was deemed too expensive to continue. The decision appears less rooted in budget discipline and more in branding preferences.

When a show that performed well is shelved, while others with higher costs and lower early engagement are renewed, the message is clear: not all franchises are treated equally—even when the data says they should be.

How Metrics Mask Reality

Disney’s internal viewership metric, calculated by dividing total hours watched by episode runtime, complicates comparisons. This method captures rewatches and background play, inflating figures and making direct comparisons murky. Still, by Disney’s own math, The Acolyte led the race.

As John Boyega once said about Star Wars backlash, some fans ‘knew what to do with Daisy Ridley, with Adam Driver… but when it came to Kelly Marie Tran, when it came to John Boyega, they didn’t know what to do with it.’ That discomfort around race and representation lingers, and The Acolyte faced similar backlash.

Two Franchises, One Uneven Standard

This moment isn’t only about numbers—it’s about how decisions are framed, and whose stories are given the room to grow. Star Wars and Marvel are Disney’s crown jewels, yet the treatment of The Acolyte and Daredevil: Born Again reveals a stark contrast. One show was cut short despite outperforming expectations. The other, with lower debut numbers, was renewed. The explanation? Budget. But the inconsistency invites deeper scrutiny.

If success alone doesn’t secure a second season, then what does? For many fans of The Acolyte, the silence from Disney feels less like strategy and more like dismissal. The show introduced bold characters, new lore, and a different tone—and that risk wasn’t rewarded with support.

But this isn’t just about viewership metrics. It’s about the stories that get labeled as flops, and the ones given the benefit of time. The numbers didn’t fail The Acolyte—the narrative around them did.

Six months isn’t a long time in the life of a fan campaign. The return of Daredevil didn’t happen overnight—it followed years of steady support, creative engagement, and belief in the character’s future. That kind of momentum builds gradually.

For those backing The Acolyte, the story may still be unfolding. Enthusiasm hasn’t faded, and conversations around the show continue to spark across platforms. Whether or not a second season happens, the impact is already visible.

The renewed success of Daredevil stands as a clear example of what fan commitment can achieve. It serves not just as a win for Marvel, but as a broader reminder of the influence audiences hold—and what’s possible when stories are allowed a second life.

Disney can still bring back The Acolyte.

Add your voice to the growing movement. Sign the petition to SaveTheAcolyte campaign and support bold, inclusive storytelling in the galaxy far, far away.

Discover more from Feminegra

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.